logo
  • Home
  • Aquatic Pets
  • Cats
  • Dogs
  • Pet Birds
  • Pet Reptiles
  • Small Pets
  • All Pets
  • Home
  • Cats
Last updated: 18 Mar 2021
Pets, Paws and Claws is supported by readers. If you click a link we may earn an affiliate commission. Click here for more information.

For a Healthy and Happy Feline, Get the Best Plush Cat Toys

Top Pick
logo
Pet Craft Supply Plush Cat Toy
Shop now
Best Size
logo
Petlinks Refillable Catnip Plush Cat Toy
Shop now
Most Soothing
logo
Petstages Purr Pillow Plush Cat Toy
Shop now
Also Consider
logo
SmartyKat Skitter Critters Plush Cat Toy
Shop now
author-image
By Charlie Forsythe
Published 25 Feb 2021
Show contents
  • 1 Pet Craft Supply Plush Cat Toy
  • 2 Petlinks Refillable Catnip Plush Cat Toy
  • 3 Petstages Purr Pillow Plush Cat Toy
  • 4 SmartyKat Skitter Critters Plush Cat Toy

Cats by nature are hunters. This can be seen in everyday behaviors, especially during playtime. They are practicing important skills even at a young age. The abilities learned are important to their overall development. Having certain tools available to them can assist in the mastery of their prowess. Plush toys are a wonderful way to accomplish this.

The plush, or stuffed animal type, toys allow felines to handle something similar to small prey. This is what they were born to do and how they have survived for millennia. The activity helps their physical health while keeping their minds sharpened. The animation observed with cats involved in this type of play is key to their vitality. The best plush toys in 2021 are ideal for this.

Best Plush Cat Toy

1

Pet Craft Supply Plush Cat Toy

– Top Pick
img
Check On Amazon
Key Features

These soft and bright toys are great for playtime. Since they are filled with catnip, your cat won’t want to stop playing.

THE SCOOP

These alluring cat toys are popular with cats. The catnip is irresistible. They will not want to let these out of their sight. The double pack is twice the fun.

Pros
  • Comes with maximum potency catnip
  • Keeps cats mentally and physically stimulated for hours
  • Ideal for all life stages of cats
Cons
  • Much smaller than indicated in photos
  • Catniip scent not as strong as other products
2

Petlinks Refillable Catnip Plush Cat Toy

– Best Size
img
Check On Amazon
Key Features

This toy is soft and has plenty of variable texture to stimulate your cat. It can be refilled with catnip for endless fun.

THE SCOOP

Large and small kitties will appreciate the size of this extra-plush toy. It also has a catnip inside that can be refilled as needed. This is a definite contender.

Pros
  • Energizes and delights cats thanks to refillable catnip container
  • Meets all applicable safety standards
  • Easy for cats to carry and toss around
Cons
  • Sometimes difficult to refill catnip container
  • Catnip pouch can be hard to find at first
3

Petstages Purr Pillow Plush Cat Toy

– Most Soothing
img
Check On Amazon
Key Features

This cute cat pillow is great for cuddling and playing with. Cats will love its size and its soothing purring that can help alleviate stress and anxiety.

THE SCOOP

This plush cat toy is ideal for cats and kittens of all ages and comes with a removable purr mechanism when you put it in the wash. The touch-activated purr lasts for two minutes and is calming.

Pros
  • Designed to provide a familiar, soothing cat purr
  • Great for cats with separation anxiety
  • Fur is soft and silky
Cons
  • Too delicate for more aggressively playful cats
  • Not all cats are drawn to the purr sounds
4

SmartyKat Skitter Critters Plush Cat Toy

– Also Consider
img
Check On Amazon
Key Features

This set of three little mice means your cat will have plenty to play with! Each mouse is filled with catnip for extra stimulation. These are even made with recycled and organic materials.

THE SCOOP

This plush cat toy has 100% recycled plastic with fiberfill, and the catnip causes a burst of energy in cats before they start to feel mellow. The catnip doesn’t contain any chemicals and pesticides.

Pros
  • Made from 100% recycled plastic
  • Comes in a pack of three
  • Mimic the size of real mice
Cons
  • Tails might be hazardous for some cats
  • Not as durable as some users hoped
author-image
By Charlie Forsythe
Charlie is the lead expert of all things pet for Paws, Claws and Tails. Coming from a pet-centric background, he has owned or taken care of every pet on our site and then some. Charlie says that the best pet isn't a certain species or breed, but the one who brings you the most joy. He is excited to bring you all of the products and guidance you need to help you and your little friend have the best, and longest, relationship possible.
  • Home
  • About
logo
Copyright Paws, Claws and Tails © 2023
  • Privacy Policy